- When every truly needy child has a home and children who already have homes are helped to stay with their parents.
- When hunger ends.
- When women and their children are treated fairly and equally around the world.
- When coercion does not exist.
- When the poor have equal rights.
- When my First Mother heals from the grief that living without me has caused her.
- When my Adoptive Mother heals from things adoption-related that no one ever bothered to help her with.
- When adoptees are asked their opinions and it makes a difference in legislation and adoption practice.
- When adoption is strictly and federally regulated.
- When adoption is simplified.
- When adoption stops amending and sealing the identities of children.
- When adoption releases the identities that belong to Adult Adoptees to the Adult Adoptees.
- When CPC clinics stop lying to pregnant women.
- When profit is removed from adoption.
- When "anonymity" is removed from any institution that helps create children.
- When the U.S. ratifies the UN's "Rights of the Child."
- When adoption and abortion are no longer slapped together.
- When adoption and infertility are no longer slapped together.
- When the United States issues an official apology for the BSE (or EMS) and makes a memorial to the lost mothers and infants.
- When all adoptees are acknowledged (step-parent, international, foster, etc.) instead of blanket-statements made about all.
- When open adoption can't be promised unless it is legally enforced.
- When countries around the world stop using orphanages to manage dependency.
- When all adoption stereotypes become unacceptable.
- When every mother is permitted to hold her own adoption record in her hands.
- When my adoption agency apologizes first to my First Mother and then to my parents for how they were treated.
- When I find a magic wand to heal the hearts of every adoptee whom I've held in my arms because nothing makes their pain go away.
- When the infant experience of surrender is acknowledged in adoption practice.
- When every adoptee knows information about themselves that will allow them to embrace every part of everyday-life just like the non-adopted do.
- When the only labels for mothers and fathers are "mother" and "father."
- When the media no longer makes fun of us, exploits our stories, or defames foster children for profit.
- When adequate sex education is provided in schools.
- When birth control is free and women's health care affordable and accessible to all.
- When homes are sought out for children in need, rather than children sought out for prospective parents, in 100% of adoption.
- When adoptees are not forced into counseling, slapped with state-mandated restraining orders, or subjected to information erasures just to see their birth certificate.
- When adoption is not a subject to be shoved in the closet but something people feel they can openly enter into dialogue about.
- When everyone in adoption understands how the other individuals involved in adoption feel and why.
- When Father's Rights and Extended Family Rights actually exist.
- When adequate and accurate information about adoption is acknowledged and widespread.
- When not one more person's life is at risk because of lack of access to genetic information.
- When not one more parent and child are unnecessarily separated.
- When religion and special-interest groups get out of my voting booth.
- When corruption ends.
- When racial equality has been achieved in society.
- When gender equality has been achieved in society.
- When everyone knows their date, country, state, and place of birth.
When everything that is wrong in adoption is fixed, every heart is healed, every belly full of food, and every tear is dried, I will "get over" being adopted.
Fair enough?
Photo credit: Jennifer Renee

It is too late for me to get over it, but if your generation and my generation can educate and speak out during our time here, perhaps we can bring about some of the changes on your list, then perhaps some future generations might have the tools needed to help them "get over it".
ReplyDeleteMay I share this post on my blog?
So, sadly, the answer is never.
ReplyDeleteGreat list. The only comments I would have are regarding the implication in #37 that fathers are relegated to extended family, as they're not. That observation ties in with #40 which in my opinion should read "When not one more parent and child are unnecessarily separated".
Also, it's necessary to have terms distinguishing the biological parent from the adoptive parent (condition #29). I guess my wish would be that unless it's blatantly derogatory, toward either type of parent, that people loosen up a bit when it comes to this.
Seems a bit trivial when held up against the rest of the conditions on the list.
Sure Liz, share away! :-) Thanks.
ReplyDeleteYou're right, we have to work together!
Amanda,
ReplyDeleteBeautifully written as usual and very very accurate...you are the best.
Cheers!
Amanda, one word. Amen.
ReplyDeleteMay I link this to the Edu Blog?
Fantastic Post. I haven't written on my blog for weeks because I have just had it with adoption up to here and beyond. But you've got me fired up again.
ReplyDeleteI will share it too.
UM
Of course Lori :-) Thanks
ReplyDeleteCampbell, I'll tweek my wording but semantics aside, I'm sure my point was made right? :-)
ReplyDeleteHow about "when adoption ceases to exist"?!
ReplyDeleteAustralia phased out child adoptions. America needs to do this as well. Kinship care and guardianship need to replace child adoptions.
Great post Amanda.
I'd like to share this, too.
Joan Wheeler
http://forbiddenfamily.com
Point was made for sure, as I said in my first comment, great list. It's just that I doubt guys/dads think of things like that as "semantics". Thanks for the consideration/tweek Amanda.
ReplyDeleteYou make a good point Campbell.
ReplyDeleteAmanda, this was wonderful and sad. Thank you for it. You are amazing!
ReplyDeleteOutstanding post Amanda, sadly I bet you've only scraped the surface.
ReplyDeleteCampbell, after going through a custody battle I am sure my son would disagree about semantics. He may be more of an exception than the rule but I think there are alot of Dads out there who get it. We only hear about the deadbeats. :-)
Bizarrely, I just got finished writing about telling a new acquaintance that I did not "get over" giving up my child. That you never "get over" it. She asked a couple of times if there "were other women who felt like me?" We need to talk talk talk to educate the public about what adoption does to both sides of the equation: mother & child.
ReplyDeleteLorraine from
Birth Mother, First Mother Forum
Great post...it seems when people feel uncomfortable with things, they expect you to "get over it". What they really want is for you to get over it so THEY don't have to deal with it. This is a common theme in the special needs moms community too. Great list!
ReplyDeleteI'll get over it with you when all those stipulations are met! Excellent!
ReplyDeleteEvidence Joan for Australia phasing out adoption?
ReplyDeleteGreat post and a great list.
More... Very Much More than "Fair enough"
ReplyDeleteBlessings!
Although one can never truly get over the damage done by adoption, I am trying to integrate the fact that I'm an adoptee into my life without allowing it to control my life, a difficult task indeed.
ReplyDeleteGreat progress will be made when we stop calling adopters "parents," when they are not (although they do fulfill a parental-type role) and when we start calling moms and dads who lose a child to adoption "a mom or dad who lost a child to adoption" instead of more demeaning terms. The pro-adoption forces in this country have done a lot to change the language of adoption (e.g., deeming the honest term "real parents" as politically incorrect) and as a result, people have the perception that adoption creates families instead of tearing them apart. Once we start being honest about adoption and unafraid to tell our stories, which I know is easier said than done, we will be on our way to ending stranger adoption of infants and children.
Bravo, Amanda!
ReplyDeleteGreat blog!
Great post.
ReplyDeleteThe problem is, in regards to #40 - what is a "necessary" adoption? If adoption wasn't necessary, would it exist? Do people want adoption to be "necessary"? If so, what constitutes what is "necessary" for an adoption to work out?
For example, you have a mother that cannot afford medical care. You have a prospective parent who would like to adopt and raise a child. The mother who cannot afford medical care feels obligated to let the prospective parent take care of her child since the prospective parent has the money.
Hypothetically, is the adoption necessary? Is it lawful according to the mother's inability to pay? Is it lawful for the prospective parent? What constitutes as "necessary" in this situation?
Mei Ling, I am an adamant family preservation advocate. You have to know what my answer to that would be :-)
ReplyDeleteA parent who is willing to parent should be helped to do so regardless of their socioeconomic status or access to health care. Seperating a mother who wants to parent her child from her child because she is poor and without access to health care, to me, is unnecessary. People should be helping her find resources, not taking her child. The resources are out there if people are willing to help someone look.
A necessary adoption (preferably guardianship or simple adoption) is one where the original parents are abusive beyond rehabilitation to become suitable parents, where the parents are deceased, or where the parents have abandoned a child with no interest in parenting. An adoption in these cases may be necessary when all other options for family preservation have been 100% exhausted.
@Amanda,
ReplyDelete"A necessary adoption (preferably guardianship or simple adoption) is one where the original parents are abusive beyond rehabilitation to become suitable parents, where the parents are deceased, or where the parents have abandoned a child with no interest in parenting. An adoption in these cases may be necessary when all other options for family preservation have been 100% exhausted. "
I have been preaching that forever! It is sad that even the adoption community is unaware that there are kids that have no options at all, and sometimes adoption is the only thing left. The states make those lives a mess, why can't they be more permanent?
I think people are aware that there are kids that have no options at all and that sometimes adoption is the only thing left but refuse to address (admit) it because they feel doing so diminishes their message of all adoption being wrong (sick).
ReplyDeleteI actually do technically have a bone to pick with all of adoption--meaning, adoption in its current form. Providing a truly needy child with a home does not need to entail all that it entails. Children who have already experienced so much should not be required to have to have their original identity sealed in order to gain the home that they deserve. When we make all of adoption about focusing on finding great homes for needy kids, we will find that we're better able to help kids be raised in their original countries or with individuals who can preserve their cultural identities. Adoption should be much simpler, more truthful, more transparent, and more honest and there is no excuse for it not to be.
ReplyDeleteWhich, I should add, is why I advocate for fostering older children from the public foster system.
ReplyDeleteLove this.
ReplyDeleteAMEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDelete