Monday, October 3, 2011

Dear "Life Chain," Your Signs Stigmatize Adoptees

I grew up in a small town where Life Chain was a big deal.  Each year my church, along with other churches and community groups, gathered and stood along major roads in neighboring towns holding signs with anti-choice messages.  I was reminded of this when friends still living in that area who I have on my Facebook page started posting pictures of this year's event and I saw the sign I used to hold "Adoption, the Loving Option."  Rather than being nostalgic, I was mortified.  Even more mortified to see people I know holding it.  To be perpetually seen as some "survivor" of an event that people think I was destined for is disempowering.  It's stereotyping.  It's completely misinformed.  It is stigmatizing not only to me but to my mother.

Abortion and adoption have nothing to do with one another.  Abortion is a decision about health care and pregnancy.  Adoption involves a decision about whether or not to parent a child who has been born.   Adoption did not "rescue" me from anything and I am less than thrilled that all some pro-lifers can think to do is value my mother by her reproductive choices.  Many women experience unplanned pregnancy; yet mothers who surrender to adoption and adoptees are the only ones to carry this stigma.

Most states place restrictions on the availability of abortions.  Contraception, pre-natal care, and child care are also extremely difficult to come by.  However, instead of advocating for contraception, adequate health care, and affordable, quality child care that women and families deserve, some are content to instead slap the concept of adoption around.  As a woman and as an adoptee, I find this insulting to say the very least.  Has no one ever asked themselves "what if a woman who doesn't have an abortion doesn't want to give her baby up for adoption?"  Because that's actually the reality here.  Do the signs have an answer for that?  Where is the "adequate support for mothers!" sign?  Where is the "free and reliable child care!" sign?  Where is the "safe and affordable health care and contraceptives!" sign?  When you peel away all of the rhetoric, I see nothing left but misinformation and certainly not genuine concern for women and their families.

Resources and care for families and children....THAT'S the loving option.

And that is all I really have to say.

10 comments:

  1. "Resources and care for families and children....THAT'S the loving option."
    Nicely put!

    ReplyDelete
  2. So, when do you want to picket the pro-lifers with signs like that? I am in! I will travel for that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very good observations, and so true. "Abortion and adoption have nothing to do with one another. Abortion is a decision about health care and pregnancy. Adoption involves a decision about whether or not to parent a child who has been born." So true. Also good points about no sympathy from Right To Life for mothers who want to raise their children, nor for contraception availability or women's health care.

    Many of us who ended up surrendering never considered abortion, so that was not the choice, and certainly not something our children "survived". Adoption and abortion have nothing to do with each other, really.

    Just another simplistic slogan promoting an agenda out of touch with the complications of real life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent post, Amanda! Thank you for succinctly wording this important message I wish others were willing to hear!

    When I first told one of my aunts I had found my daughter lost to adoption, her "loving" comment was "good you didn't abort her". It felt like she had punched me in the gut. Here I was sharing my elation and joy and that was her response. I haven't been able to feel the same about her since. :-(

    Amanda, I've said it before and will say it again...I am so glad you are blogging. You are making a difference in so many ways.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As a mother who tried to have an abortion--and failed, too late, it was 1966 and illegal--my life and feelings totally turned around by the time I had my baby. I hate it when birth mothers are celebrated, as you say, for not having an abortion, because one can want an abortion...but then very much want to keep and love the child you give birth to.

    As usual, great post.
    XX
    lorraine

    ReplyDelete
  6. Excellent post Amanda. I had to listen to the rhetoric in church last weekend, and so badly wanted to stand up and yell "Abortion and Adoption have nothing to do with each other!".

    Just imagine if all those people would put as much energy into supporting moms and their children what could be done.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Excellent post! Always the voice of reason but speaking the emotional truth.

    Marianne

    ReplyDelete
  8. Re Comment Posting Difficulties: I always had trouble commenting using my blog host designation but if I just use Name and URL it seems to work every time.

    ReplyDelete
  9. As I drive to and from here and there this month, I have the "pleasure" of passing all of the white crosses in church yards that "represent" abortion. I like to call this "geez, I'm so grateful no one aborted me month". It's such an insult. It's another one of the unspoken things in the world that make adoptees feel like they NEED to be grateful and thankful and blah, blah, blah.

    ReplyDelete

Please comment. I love hearing from you!

Commenting Guidelines:
--Feel free to respectfully agree or disagree, discuss with others, share how you felt, what you thought, what information you know, or something you've experienced.
--Anonymous commenting has been enabled for those who feel more comfortable commenting that way. Please put a little nickname, number, or alias of some sort with your anonymous comment to reduce confusion if multiple anons start commenting and discussing in the post at the same time.
--Word verification has been enabled to reduce spam. If you have difficulty seeing the verification, feel free to email me your comment at declassifiedadoptee [at] gmail [dot] com and I will post it for you.

I reserve the right to delete comments at my discretion.

Having trouble making a comment? Sometimes my blog host has technical difficulty. Try back later. If you came here from Networked Blogs on Facebook, go up to the top of the page and hit the little "x" on the right-hand side of the gray Networked Blogs tool bar to exit out of their frame. You should be able to comment then. If all else fails, email me and I will post your comment for you.

Posts You May Also Like....

Related Posts with Thumbnails